Thursday, 28 February 2013

Around the Traps 1/3/13

Here we are again. So these are the highlights as I see them.

Aussie Aussie Aussie Oy Oy Oy



General



Austerity in Europe


Sequestration in the US


Statistics (Well mostly actually all  Andrew Gelman)


Wonkish

Vox Wonk




Diet(?)




Wednesday, 27 February 2013

Unbelievable

I missed this and had to be told of it.


Stagflation Davidson said something about global warming.

I now hand over to this column.
John Quiggin says this
"his is just a demonstration that Davidson’s idiot readers don’t understand the concept of statistical significance, and that Davidson (who knows the score) doesn’t care to enlighten them. The question at issue is “how much data do you need to be 95 per cent confident that the observed warming couldn’t have arisen by chance”. With annual data and a simple linear regression, the answer (given by Phil Jones) is that the data from 1995 to 2009 (when he was first asked) wasn’t enough, but the data from 1995 to 2012 is sufficient.
Davidson’s trick is that, if you allow for autocorrelation in the monthly data, you need a longer time period to get 95 per cent confidence. With the data since 1995, there’s a 20 per cent chance that the observed warming could have arisen by chance. Since we have satellite data going back to 1979, and surface data going back 100 years, that fact is irrelevant except to the morons who comment at Catallaxy, but Davidson is happy to play on the ignorance of his readers.
Of course, the real shame here goes to Richard Lindzen who originated this utterly dishonest line of argument. Lindzen has trashed a record of achievement that would have had him remembered as a significant contributor to science. Davidson has nothing to lose, and the applause of his idiot followers to gain."
then NickR says this
"I’d argue that Davidson’s work is far worse than that. He effectively imposes a structural break in 1995 but does so with reference to the data. Endogeneously placing a structural break makes the inference he performs with regular t statistics incorrect.
His argument here is that Phil Jones did it, so if you disagree explain why he is wrong. Incredible chutzpah really as Jones did it and drew the *correct* conclusion while Davidson is doing it to support the *incorrect* conclusion.
He also corrects for autocorrelation in two ways. Firstly with his AR(1) error (which is not necessary for the hypothesis he wishes to test and therefore a violation of Occam’s Razor) and secondly with Newy West standard errors. He is right to be concerned about the effect of autocorrelation on his inference, but to correct for it twice is to deliberately waste information. He then builds his case on their being insufficient information to establish a trend."
and then john Quiggin says this
"Obviously, there’s no reason to think anything changed in 1995, and a test of the full data set would, I’m sure, reject the hypothesis of a structural break. This is just a piece of trickery, playing on the gullibility and wishful thinking of the delusionist audience.
On yoour other point, I haven’t kept up with the latest in time-series econometrics, but I think you’re right. If you are going to use Newey-West standard errors to correct for autocorrelation, you shouldn’t also impose an AR(1) error structure."

The only thing I will say is that it is strange ( highly euphemistic) to state bit it is a Phil Jones test when it was Lindzen
say no more.

Sinclair, Goebbels started out as a super smart propagandist but ended up by 1938 believing his own bulldust!
There must be a reason why Katesy is as mad as a hatter. Be afraid be very afraid.  
Beware of the dark side!!!

Tuesday, 26 February 2013

Fiscal policy in the future

In Australia we have the budget delivered in May. This is the Government of the day's fiscal statement for the fiscal year ( July to June).

As we have discussed in recent days fiscal policy is a means to an end. At present it is contractionary or the government is pursuing austerity.

As we have seen pursuing austerity in a boom as Keynes pointed out in 1937 makes perfect sense but it doesn't make sense when nominal GDP is below trend and continuing to fall.

Does this mean the Government should start spending again?  No. Even though things are not normal yet ( the revenue figures tell us that) we can for the moment rely on automatic stabilisers and  looser monetary policy.
The only thing policymakers can't control is the continuing high level of the $A.

As things get back to 'normal' then the budget will get back into balance.

The politics of such a policy is different but that is because
1) The Government can't explain its fiscal policy
2) The Opposition doesn't understand its policy position. ( This assumes they are telling us their actual policy position.) I will write about this closer to the election.

Monday, 25 February 2013

Fiscal Policy now

We have talked before about how if nominal GDP growth remains below trend then the budget will not get into the black. ( see this for example).

One of the more savvy operators believes the final budget outcome could be $16b deficit.

As it is this is no bad thing. The budget bottom line is NOT an end in itself , it is a means to an end. That end is stronger GDP growth.

It is highly ironic that most critics of the government not achieving a balanced budget advocate solutions which would make the deficit higher. They wish the government make greater spending cuts. This is what Wayne Swan was originally trying to do. However he was obviously advised to change his mind. ( Martin Parkinson and Glenn Stevens have recently made comments to Parliamentary comments to this effect.)
( see this for example.)

Why is this?
To understand this you need to comprehend two things.
1) The structural part of the budget has a much greater effect on the economy.
2) The cyclical part of the budget has a much greater effect on the budget bottom line.

Thus if the government tried to cut further to achieve a balanced budget they would in fact achieve the opposite. They would further slowdown the economy. ( Remembering of course the present budget is already contractionary and thus detracting from GDP growth.)
A contracting economy means increased expenditures and reduced tax revenues. In other words the European disease.

Before nominal GDP growth slowed to go below trend fiscal policy was quite appropriate ( and keynesian).
contractionary fiscal policy is what is needed when the private sector 'powers up'. however once nominal GDP growth went below trend fiscal policy was contributing to a slowing economy.

When nominal GDP growth comes back to trend the budget will be in balance. Whilst it isn't then leave the automatic stabilisers to do their job and hope monetary policy eventually turns things around.
It is also highly ironic that the other reason to impose a contractionary effect on the economy is the $A. It is ironic because overseas investors just want to buy our bonds. If they didn't nominal GDP would not be hit as hard and of course nor would the budget bottom line.

Sunday, 24 February 2013

The GFC, A Counter-Factual

We know now if not for the Government's actions Australia would have experienced a recession following the GFC.
It must be said this only occurred after Ken Henry and Glen Stevens literally pounded the need for government action into Wayne Swan's head.

However what if the coalition had won in 2007. What would have they done?

I think we can assume they might have done one of three things.

1) They could have done nothing. Insisting they had a tight budget and the need to maintain a budget surplus.
However we could assume the structural deficit would have been larger and then  made artificially larger once the GFC hit revenues. Automatic stabilisers would have also hit the bottom line evaporating the surplus before our eyes. On this scenario unemployment would have rocketed up past 8% perhaps even hitting 10% before levelling out.
I rate this only a 20% probability

2) They could have reacted to the GFC like New Zealand , Canada or Sweden. However this would have occurred after the event so even on this scenario unemployment would have risen to around  at least 8%.
If tax cuts would have been the major area of policy then this would have made the deficit worse than under the stimulus. The reason of course tax cuts have a constant effect on revenues whereas a stimulus has only a short effect on spending patterns as we have seen.
I rate this a 80% probability

3) They could have attempted to maintain a budget surplus. Cutting spending and raising taxation.
This of course would have probably made a depression (a fall in GDP of over 10%) inevitable.
Unemployment would have risen to at least 15% and the deficit and debt ratios would have blown out enormously like Ireland or Estonia. ( see this for example) I rate this a nil % probability.

Over the next couple of days we will examine what fiscal policy is at present and what it should be over the next couple of years.

Friday, 22 February 2013

Midnight Oil

When I was young I travelled to the Royal Antler hotel at North Narrabeen to watch a young band called Midnight Oil.

They had energy!

The funniest time was when we went there after playing cricket. Four blokes in cricket whites! I drove and therefore didn't drink.

A shout of 3 schooners of beer and one of orchy came to around  $1!!

This is their best song

Thursday, 21 February 2013

Around the Traps 22/2/13

Okay it is Friday and it is time to see what people have been writing about in the blogosphere.

Aussie Aussie Aussie Oy oy Oy!

General
Minimum wages in the US
Wonkish
Vox Wonk ( Love that!) Bookmark the site.
Statistics well mainly Andrew Gelman