Kruggers has interesting information on Alesina & Ardagna.
I have written about this previously. In Oz we have this from John Quiggin. And then this as well.
Have a read of the Catallaxy thread and see how people will avoid talking about the topic.
Classical economics has failed every nation that has tried it EXCEPT in circumstances that Keynes specified.
Funnily enough Sinclair Davidson agrees with Keynes ( although he doesn't realise it). You can only have successful austerity programs when spending falls as a % of GDP.
That ONLY occurs when the economy s healthy not when it is weak.
This is just another example of people such as Davidson, Carling, Kirchner and of course Katesy avoiding the major question.
They are all dishonest charlatans!
The R&R paper, as distinct from the book, merely adding to this dishonesty.
Postscript.
Kruggers has it right about evidence-and-economic-policy.
Austerians, for wont of another word ,are just like old fashioned communists. Forget, ignore or deny any evidence and live only for the ideology.
Postscript 2
Austerity did not get Australia out of the Depression. We nailed that Julie Novak falsehood previously
Okay I have assumed too much here.
A&A got demolished by the IMF study ( now a working paper). Their response was a non-response.
When Carling & Krichner's piece in the AFR got severe criticism from John Quiggin their response was a non-response.
Similarly when R&R in the latest skirrmish got criticised their response was a non-response.
Tuesday, 23 April 2013
Monday, 22 April 2013
A - League Final
The A-League has had a tremendous season.
Most of this can be put down at the feet of the Western Sydney Wanderers fans.
They have been a breath of fresh air and a revelation to the A-League.
I have said previously one should go to a match of the Wanderers just to catch the atmosphere created by them.
Thus they did this in the final but alas their team lost the game to the Central Coast Mariners 0-2.
As a Referee I have to say I am still wondering how the Wanderers did not get two penalties. They did concede one and it was given but I am completely mystified on the two not given.
Finals are rarely great games because both teams simply want to win and invariably one team doesn't rise to the occasion.
I think it was so on Sunday.
Congratulations to the Mariners for finally winning a final but also a huge congratulations to the Wanderers on a wonderful first season.
I for one am looking forward to watching them in the Asian champions league.
UPDATE
Both the SMH and Telegraph have articles on the Wanderers fans. When a Rugby League diehard like Phil Rothfield gets so worked up by the WSW fans he says the A-League final has it over any other sports final you know something special happened.
Most of this can be put down at the feet of the Western Sydney Wanderers fans.
They have been a breath of fresh air and a revelation to the A-League.
I have said previously one should go to a match of the Wanderers just to catch the atmosphere created by them.
Thus they did this in the final but alas their team lost the game to the Central Coast Mariners 0-2.
As a Referee I have to say I am still wondering how the Wanderers did not get two penalties. They did concede one and it was given but I am completely mystified on the two not given.
Finals are rarely great games because both teams simply want to win and invariably one team doesn't rise to the occasion.
I think it was so on Sunday.
Congratulations to the Mariners for finally winning a final but also a huge congratulations to the Wanderers on a wonderful first season.
I for one am looking forward to watching them in the Asian champions league.
UPDATE
Both the SMH and Telegraph have articles on the Wanderers fans. When a Rugby League diehard like Phil Rothfield gets so worked up by the WSW fans he says the A-League final has it over any other sports final you know something special happened.
Saturday, 20 April 2013
The "Right" in Australia are a disgrace continued
The IPA put out a paper on public sector employment.
The fact it was put out by the IPA immediately gives way to suspicion. They are rarely correct.
It was authored by Julie Novak whom we have caught outdoctoring unable to discern GDP figures during the Great Depression.
Thus it proves so.
Matt Cowgill looks behind the figures and finds some very strange ( highly euphemistic) data collection.
In short it is complete cobblers which appeals only to idiots who are too stupid or too lazy to find out the data is highly suspect.
I should have added they also have no shame at all.
The fact it was put out by the IPA immediately gives way to suspicion. They are rarely correct.
It was authored by Julie Novak whom we have caught out
Thus it proves so.
Matt Cowgill looks behind the figures and finds some very strange ( highly euphemistic) data collection.
In short it is complete cobblers which appeals only to idiots who are too stupid or too lazy to find out the data is highly suspect.
I should have added they also have no shame at all.
Thursday, 18 April 2013
Around the Traps 19/4/13 Special Rogoff and Reinhart edition
It is Friday in Sydanee and so time for Around the Traps.
UPDATE. It is teeming down here today so no football . Thus I have added to Around the Traps
We have had much controversy concerning Rogoff and Reinhart thus I give them a special section with lots of views on their work.
Many thanks to Mark Thoma who must never sleep and puts up wonderful items on his great blog. We loves ya in OZ Mark!!
I will update when I can. however the great Western Sydanee Wanderers are in the A-League final so no promises.
Enjoy
Aussie,Aussie,Aussie,Oy,Oy,Oy
US
Andrew Gelman(Statistics really)
General
Wonk
Voxwonk
UPDATE. It is teeming down here today so no football . Thus I have added to Around the Traps
We have had much controversy concerning Rogoff and Reinhart thus I give them a special section with lots of views on their work.
Many thanks to Mark Thoma who must never sleep and puts up wonderful items on his great blog. We loves ya in OZ Mark!!
I will update when I can. however the great Western Sydanee Wanderers are in the A-League final so no promises.
Enjoy
Aussie,Aussie,Aussie,Oy,Oy,Oy
- Harry Clarke celebrates the us-masters
- John Quiggin on there-is-a-world-market-for-maybe-five-computers
- Mark Banisch on so-much-for-the-education-revolution
- Mumble on the_nodding_position, cause_and_effect_malfunction and zero_sum_game_of_mavericks
- Antony Green on barnaby-joyce-new-england-and-his-senate-seat
- Ricardian Ambivalence says commonwealth-budget-on-track-for-20bn-deficit ( no bad thing),what-can-we-learn-from-nz-cpi and gross-flows-and-long-term-unemployment and very very late ( Bad RA) gdp-was-what?
- Brian Banisch on tipping-point-for-climate-action
- Grog's Gamut on drum-piece-progressive-tax-and-flat-tax,Sinclair Davidson says it is flat-tax-nonsense . Just a pityhe never read the Henry tax review though!
- Kevin Bonham on liberty-abortion-and-salamanca
- Peter Martin finds hockey-that-surplus-promise-ditch-it. His comments show he still doesn't understnd the fiscal position though
US
- Mark Thoma on fed-watch-when-can-we-all-admit-the-euro-is-an-economic-failure
- Canada actually but Frances Woolley on a-day-in-the-life-of-a-behavioural-economist
- Calculated Risk on shiller-and-upward-slope-of-real-house and key-measures-show-low-inflation-in-march and very very late ( Bad CR)update-federal-and-state-improving
- Robert Waldeman on mark-thoma-qe-and-signalling
- Steve Roth on solow-on-bernanke, reading-mankiw-in-seattle
- Noah Smith on will-land-prices-rise-as-population
- Jared Bernstein says the-president-is-right-about-faster-growth-shrinking-the-deficit
- Tim Duy via Mark Thoma says fed-watch-another-spring-slowdown
- Menzies Chim on the_great_divergance( US v UK) and no_time_for_austerity_ in_ US
- Antonio Fatas on the-never-ending-recovery
- Brad DeLong gives us Barry Eichengreen europe-fails-to-learn-the-lessons-of-history-notes-on-political-union-for-barry-eichengreens-future-of-the-euro-conference (really good)
- Kruggers on dnwr-in-the-ea and europe-in-brief
- John McHale on simon-wren-lewis-on-a-different-kind-of-lender-of-last-resort, mario-draghi-the-role-of-monetary-policy-in-addressing-the-crisis-in-the-euro-area ( with lots of links and useful comments to boot!)
- Simon Wren-Lewis on framing-taxpayers-money-and-fiscal-space
- Philip Lane on rethinking-macro-policy-ii-getting-granular
- Tim Duy via Mark Thoma fed-watch-accepting-failure
Andrew Gelman(Statistics really)
- why-girls-do-better-in-school
- detecting-predictability-in-complex-ecosystems
- how-effective-are-football-coaches? Andrew is actually talking about gridiron not the beautiful game!!
- data-problems-coding-errors-what-can-be-done
- excel-bashing
- Good stats Bad stats on home price confusion and cost of child care going up?
General
- Owen Zidar gives us larry-summers-reviews-the-history-of-austerity
- Simon Wren-Lewis on why-dual-mandate-is-essential and then Robert Waldeman on inflation-targets-and-rewriting-history and very very late ( bad Simon wait for Monday!!)the-stupid-cruelty-of-creditor.html
- Frances Woolley on whats-a-man-worth-on-the-dating-market
- Kruggers on missing-deflation
- Lord Keynes on says-law-overview-and-bibliography, the-nature-of-time-science-and-economics
- Macroblog on higher-education-a-deflating-bubble
- Economic principals about getting serious about climate change ( thanks Mark Thoma)
- Scientific Americam on why-grad-schools-should-require-students-to-blog
- Fata and Mihow on single-mandate-or-fear-of-inflation
- Ricardian Ambivalence reviews the-secret-race (drugs in bike riding)
- Steve Roth continues his barrage okay-fine-lets-call-investment-saving, saving-investment-and-lending-in-real-economy
- Menzies Chin on gold_prices_falling
- John Quiggin on the-bitcoin-bubble-and-a-bad-hypothesis
- David Glasner on david-laidler-on-hawtrey-and-the-treasury-view and the-golden-constant-my-eye
Wonk
- Brad De Long says its-the-seventieth-anniversary-of-abba-lerners-functional-finance
- Mark Thoma on financial-stability-monitoring
- Nick Rowe on did-inflation-targeting-make-the-phillips-curve-really-flatter-or-just-look-flatter
- Kruggers on holy-coding-error-batman, reinhart-rogoff-continued , further-further-thoughts-on-death-by-excel and blame-the-pundits-too, very late but correlation-causality-and-casuistry even later lack-of-nuance-is-not-the-problem
- Mark Thoma how-much-unemployment-was-caused-by-reinhart-and-rogoffs-arithmetic-mistake
- Jared Bernstein not-to-pile-on-but-correcting-reinhart-and-rogoff , the-political-economy-of-reinhartrogoff-and-the-austerity-debate
- Andrew Gelman says memo-to-reinhart-and-rogoff-i-think-its-best-to-admit-your-errors-and-go-on-from-there
- Mark Thoma on empirical-methods-and-progress-in-macroeconomics
- Simon Wren-Lewis on reduced-form-macro and an-understandable-mistake
- Dan Crawford on empirical-methods-and-progress-in-macroeconomics
- Noah Smith on what-if-all-those-times-really-were
- Peter Dorman on ken-rogoff-and-carmen-reinhart-meet-Marc Hauser
- Seamus Coffey on reinhart-rogoff-the-rejoinder
- Ricardian Ambivalence on the-reinhart-rogoff-recrunch-er
- Mike Konzal on researchers-finally-replicated-reinhart-rogoff-and-there-are-serious-problems
- Rortybomb guest post on reinhartrogoff-and-growth-time-debt
- Livio De Matteo on debt-and-growth
- Very very late ( Bad bad Brad)reinhart-rogoff-weblogging-no-their-argument-for-austerity-now-didnt-make-sense
- Via Brad DeLong gavyn-davies-on-reinhartrogoff
- Steve Roth on note-to-reinhartrogoff-et-al-the-cause-usually-precedes-the-effect
- VERY VERY VERY Late ( Bad Kaiser) however Kaiser Fong says occupational-hazards-in-data-science
- EVEN LATER James Hailton on reinhartrogoff
- SAME Robert Waldeman on a-bit-on-public-debt-gdp-growth-and-causation
Voxwonk
- ringfencing-and-consolidated-bank-stress-tests
- do-elite-universities-admit-academically-best-students
- aid-trade-can-it-be-evaluated
- inflation-targeting-dead-central-banking-after-crisis
- measuring-credit-crunch
- are-germans-really-poorer-spaniards-italians-and-greeks
- geoengineering-and-abatement-flat-relationship-under-uncertainty
- augmented-inflation-targeting-le-roi-est-mort-vive-le-roi
- fighting-financial-protectionism
- macroprudential-rebalancing
- why-global-recovery-different
- distilling-macroeconomic-news-flow
Wednesday, 17 April 2013
Beach Boys
The Beach boys were a feel good group.
Here are two of their songs
First their best. Do it again
and the Sloop John B.
Even with sad lyrics it felt good!!
Here are two of their songs
First their best. Do it again
and the Sloop John B.
Even with sad lyrics it felt good!!
Sunday, 14 April 2013
Know your Subject
Judy Sloan after being completely embarrassed by the Kouk on government debt has a go at examining the budget.
However the confusion is still evident.
She says
We get a bit later this
Let us make it easy for Ms Sloan. if nominal GDP is slowing and below trend ( because of a fall in the TOT and contractionary fiscal policy) then it is ludicrous to expect let alone support a proposal to have the budget balanced.
UPDATE
Ricardian Ambivalence examines this topic. Notice the HUGE difference in quality on the subject!
However the confusion is still evident.
She says
"no doubt, Swan will continue to drone on about how much revenue has been ‘written off’ since the GFC – complete tosh, by the way "
Please note the evidence she uses to support this claim.Complete tosh? We have looked at this previously. In short if tax as a % of GDP are at levels last seen in Keating's time then the only person talking tosh is Ms Sloan.
We get a bit later this
"A revenue increase of over 7 per cent is actually very good, particularly given how low inflation is"Again note the evidence to support this claim.
Let us make it easy for Ms Sloan. if nominal GDP is slowing and below trend ( because of a fall in the TOT and contractionary fiscal policy) then it is ludicrous to expect let alone support a proposal to have the budget balanced.
UPDATE
Ricardian Ambivalence examines this topic. Notice the HUGE difference in quality on the subject!
Thursday, 11 April 2013
Around the Traps 12/4/13 Maggie Thatcher Edition
It is Friday yet again down under and I have a special Maggie Thatcher section.
I would appreciate if anyone has seen anymore pieces on Maggie Thatcher ,sympathetic ones in particular
Aussie,Aussie,Aussie,Oy,Oy,Oy
General
Europe
Andrew Gelman(Statistics actually)
Wonk
Voxwonk
I would appreciate if anyone has seen anymore pieces on Maggie Thatcher ,sympathetic ones in particular
Aussie,Aussie,Aussie,Oy,Oy,Oy
- Guy looks at carbon-tax-repeal-rhetoric-and-reality
- Matt Cowgill writes on on-tax-expenditures/ and then looks at how-would-we-know-if-the-labour-market-was-flexible
- Don Arthur asks does-radical-welfare-reform-require-cultural-change?
- Mumble on time_to_get_boring,, how_labor_can_win , greens_and_the_labor_vote andvalues_schmalues
- Possum on megapoll-full-breakdowns
- Grogs' Gamut on drum-piece-socio-economic-advantage
- Ricardian Ambivalence talks about-that-rba-easing-bias and very latemarch-jobs-report-little-changed
- Gordon on why-the-alp-should-return-to-the-hawke-and-keating-period-of-electoral-governance
- Sinclair Davidson asks how-is-that-stimulus-working. err fiscal policy is contractionary Sinclair. wow
- John Quiggin is exasperated about people being unable to be counting-to-three
- The Kouk on some-facts-on-the-rba-dividend-molehill or why does Stutch have a job?
- Very Very late but Harry Clarke on high-speed-rail-on-australias-east-coast
- Jim Hamilton on is_the_recovery_dying?
- Steve Roth on saving doesn't equal saving resources and then follows up and up again
- Calculated Risk on existing-home-inventory
- Canada actually but Frances Woolley says were-free-up-here-too-eh
General
- Noah Smith ,who we learn has noah opinion (getit),wonders about a-world-without-macroeconomists , two-versions-of-goodharts-law and solar-is-libertarian-nuclear-is-statist
- Kruggers says we-get-results-japan-edition it just took them 15 years to do it!, doing-the-math ,deficit-derangement-syndrome
- Pro-growth liberal looks at factor-price-equalization-outsourcing
- Ricardian Ambivalence on this-time-is-different-boj-edition
- Lord Keynes on origin-of-money-and-coins,herbert-hoover-rejected-keynesianism and that-liquidationism-passage-in-hoovers-memiors
- Simon Wren-Lewis on nasty-politics-in-hard-times and myths-and-realities-of-1970s
- David Glasner and hawtrey-and-the-treasury-view ( a must read if you are interested in economic history or monetary economics)
- Via Mark Thoma did-the-fed-cause-the-housing-bubble? and another is-the-real-interest-rate-too-high-or-too-low (you need to read Kruggers
- Scientific American shows new-method-proves-climate-change-is-real
- Menzies Chin on some_new_estimates_on_Japanese_trade_elasticties
- Sandwichman on of-property-and-mercantilist-fallacy
Europe
- Mark Thoma on the-commission-on-portugal-is-this-for-real and blind-to-the-obvious-in-europe
- Kruggers on the-ecb-omt-and-moral-hazard
- Philip Lane on reliance-on-austerity-is-counterproductive-says-former-imf-mission-chief
- Very later but Simon Wren-Lewis on the-ecb-as-lender-of-last-resort-to-governments
- Kruggers and again
- voxeu
- another voxeu
- john quiggin
- David Glasner
- harry clarke
- larvatusprodeo
- Lord Keynes and more
- mumble sort of
- Duncum Weldon on 1981-and-the-364-redux
- Simon Wren-Lewis (Best one)
- Dan Crawford
- VERY VERY late but Don Arthur
- and Paul Frijters
Andrew Gelman(Statistics actually)
- scatterplot-charades
- the-supreme-court-meets-the-fallacy-of-the-one-sided-bet
- continuing-conflict-over-conflict-statistics
- Good stats Bad stats looks at whether AP exams measure school performance
Wonk
- rajiv-sethi-haircuts-on-intrade ( via Mark thoma , who else!!)
Dan CrawfordMike Kimel on the-fed-primary-dealers-and-the-ineffectiveness-of-monetary-policy- Mark Thoma on solow-has-financialization-gone-too-far
- Econbrowser guest contribution on currency_wars_v _currency_spillovers
- late but David Glasner asks -gold-bubble-is-bursting-whos-to-blame?
Voxwonk
- banking-union-eurozone
- budget-balance-structural-unemployment-and-fiscal-adjustments-spanish-case
- financial-crises-questions-and-lessons
- Is-more-finance-better-disentangling-intermediation-and-size-effects-financial-systems
- measuring-potential-output-eye-financial-cycle
- social-multiplier-versus-social-norms-what-matters-most-outcomes
- measuring-potential-output-eye-financial-cycle
- asian-noodle-bowl-when-preferences-are-underused
- measuring-clarity-central-bank-communication
- distorted-beliefs-and-financial-sector
- federal-reserve-breeding-next-financial-crisis
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)